Noble Cane
← Sugar Knowledge

Best Brown Sugar Substitutes (and How Much to Use)

Baking scene with cookies and a bowl of golden brown cane sugar

The closest brown sugar substitute is a whole cane sugar like jaggery powder, panela or muscovado, swapped 1:1. If you only have white sugar, mix 1 cup white sugar with 1 tablespoon of molasses for light brown sugar or 2 tablespoons for dark. Coconut sugar also swaps 1:1 but is drier.

What makes a good brown sugar substitute?

Brown sugar is white sugar coated in molasses, so the best substitutes bring the same two things: a caramel, molasses flavor and a bit of moisture.

Brown sugar does more than sweeten. The molasses gives cookies their chew, keeps cakes soft and adds a toffee flavor that plain sugar can't.

A good swap matches those qualities. Sugars that still contain their molasses, like jaggery, panela and muscovado, come closest. Dry sugars such as coconut sugar or turbinado work too, but your bakes may come out a little crisper.

1. Jaggery powder or other whole cane sugar

Jaggery powder is the closest match for brown sugar because it is cane juice cooked down with all of its molasses still in it.

Whole cane sugars, sold as jaggery, panela, piloncillo or rapadura, were never separated from their molasses in the first place. That gives them a deeper caramel flavor than brown sugar and a similar soft, slightly moist texture.

Use it 1:1 by volume in cookies, banana bread, granola, oatmeal and spice cakes. Powdered jaggery measures like regular sugar, while blocks of panela or piloncillo need to be grated first.

Noble Cane Mineral Sugar is 100% cane jaggery milled fine, and it swaps 1:1 for brown sugar. You can find it at noblecanesugar.com/shop.

2. White sugar plus molasses

Mixing 1 cup of white sugar with 1 tablespoon of molasses makes light brown sugar, and 2 tablespoons makes dark brown sugar.

This is the classic pantry fix, because it is exactly how most brown sugar is made. Stir or pulse the molasses into the sugar until the color is even, then measure it like brown sugar.

No molasses? Maple syrup can stand in at the same ratio. The flavor will be lighter and less toffee-like, but the moisture helps keep cookies chewy.

3. Muscovado sugar

Muscovado is a dark, sticky cane sugar that keeps most of its molasses. It swaps 1:1 for dark brown sugar and gives an even stronger molasses flavor.

It is a great fit for gingerbread, sticky toffee pudding, barbecue sauce and chocolate baking. For delicate cakes, mix it half and half with white sugar so it doesn't take over.

4. Coconut sugar

Coconut sugar swaps 1:1 for brown sugar and has a mild caramel taste. It is drier and more granular, so cookies may spread less and come out a bit crisper.

To get closer to brown sugar, add a teaspoon of molasses or maple syrup per cup, or a little extra butter or liquid to the dough.

5. Turbinado or demerara sugar

Turbinado and demerara are large golden crystals with a light molasses coating. They swap 1:1 but don't hold moisture the way brown sugar does, and the big crystals can stay crunchy.

They shine as a topping on muffins, crumbles and creme brulee. In doughs, grind them finer first or dissolve them in the melted butter.

6. Honey or maple syrup

Liquid sweeteners work in a pinch. Use about 3/4 cup of honey or maple syrup for every 1 cup of brown sugar, cut the other liquid in the recipe by about 1/4 cup, and lower the oven temperature by 25°F so the outside doesn't brown too fast.

Texture will change: cookies come out softer and more cake-like. Liquid sweeteners are best in quick breads, granola, sauces and marinades.

Which substitute should you pick?

For the closest flavor and texture, use jaggery powder, panela or muscovado. For a quick fix from what's already in your cupboard, use white sugar plus molasses. For toppings, use turbinado or demerara.

Whichever you choose, store it sealed in a cool, dry cupboard. Whole cane sugars and brown sugar can clump if left open; a small clump breaks up easily with a spoon.

Brown sugar substitutes at a glance
SubstituteUse per 1 cup brown sugarBest for
Jaggery powder / whole cane sugar1 cupCookies, banana bread, coffee, granola
White sugar + molasses1 cup sugar + 1 to 2 tbsp molassesAny recipe
Muscovado1 cupGingerbread, chocolate, sauces
Coconut sugar1 cupCookies, muffins (slightly crisper)
Turbinado or demerara1 cupToppings, crumbles
Honey or maple syrup3/4 cup, less 1/4 cup liquidQuick breads, sauces

Quick answers

What can I use instead of brown sugar?

Jaggery powder, panela or muscovado swap 1:1 and come closest in flavor. You can also mix 1 cup white sugar with 1 to 2 tablespoons of molasses, or use coconut sugar 1:1.

Can I use white sugar instead of brown sugar?

Yes, 1:1, but cookies will be crisper and paler with less caramel flavor. Adding 1 tablespoon of molasses per cup of white sugar makes it behave like light brown sugar.

Is jaggery a good substitute for brown sugar?

Yes. Jaggery is cane juice cooked down with its molasses still in it, so it brings the same caramel flavor and soft texture. Use jaggery powder 1:1 in place of brown sugar.

How do I make dark brown sugar from light brown sugar?

Add 1 tablespoon of molasses per cup of light brown sugar and mix until even. Or swap in muscovado, which is naturally dark.

Can I use coconut sugar instead of brown sugar?

Yes, 1:1. Coconut sugar is drier, so cookies may spread less. A teaspoon of molasses or maple syrup per cup brings it closer to brown sugar.

Keep reading

Taste the difference.

Raw cane jaggery and organic cane sugar for coffee, tea and baking.

Shop the sugars